Comparison
Use WiFi Heatmap (wifiheatmap.app) when the numbers have to stand up: its 154 models carry the antenna gain and transmit power from each vendor’s own datasheet, marked where a vendor prints no power, across 20 vendors including every brand Signal Plan lists. It has no ads, plans the cabling and PoE too, and Pro is €39 once. Signal Plan picks the model and the count for you, free, lists more models, and sells a single clean export for $6. Across the 24 rows below we take 7, Signal Plan takes 6, and 11 are even.
Every claim read from Signal Plan’s methodology, Pro page and planner, logged out, last verified 19 November 2026. Its recommendation step sits behind a human check our browsers cannot pass, so the rows about it quote Signal Plan’s own description.
Signal Plan: one power for all
Every access point is planned at 15 dBm plus its antenna gain, less 2 dB, so it is balanced with a typical phone. That is a sound design rule, and it makes the model you pick matter only through its antenna gain. Of its 195 models, 68 have gain and streams checked against a vendor datasheet and 95 are family-level estimates, by its own count.
WiFi Heatmap: each model’s own figures
Every model carries the transmit power and antenna gain its vendor publishes for each band, with the datasheet link in the catalogue. Where a vendor prints no power, as for 13 of 154, the model says “Tx estimated”. Turn any access point down by hand to plan for the phone’s uplink instead.
The rest is how each one is paid for. Signal Plan is free with ads, charges per clean export and sells Pro by the year; we have no ads and sell Pro once. Pick the one whose trade you would rather make.
7 rows favour us, 6 favour Signal Plan, 11 are a genuine tie. The tally is counted from the table, not written by hand.
Signal Plan lists more models. We read more of each one off its datasheet, and we use the transmit power the vendor publishes rather than one power for every model.
| Dimension | WiFi Heatmap | Signal Plan | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brands Every brand it names is in ours; EnGenius is in ours and not in its list. | 20 vendors: Ubiquiti, TP-Link, Aruba, Ruckus, Cisco Meraki, Cisco, Zyxel, EnGenius, MikroTik, Cambium, Netgear, Fortinet, Huawei, Juniper Mist, Extreme Networks, Ruijie, WatchGuard, Grandstream, D-Link, Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise | 22 brands, counting Cisco Meraki and Catalyst, Aruba and Instant On, TP-Link Omada and Deco, and D-Link Nuclias and DAP apart; a “Generic” set besides | Even |
| Access point models | 154 models | 195 models, Wi-Fi 5 to Wi-Fi 7 | Signal Plan |
| Where each model’s figures come from Signal Plan marks which is which in its planner, which is honest; the counts are from its own review of 9 November 2026. | Transmit power and antenna gain read off the vendor’s own datasheet, with the link on every entry; the 13 models whose vendor prints no transmit power are marked “Tx estimated” | Antenna gain and streams: 68 of 195 checked against a vendor datasheet, 32 against a retailer listing, 95 family-level estimates | WiFi Heatmap |
| Transmit power in the model Two defensible rules answering different questions: theirs plans for the phone’s weaker uplink, ours shows what the hardware can do. Under theirs, changing the model moves the heatmap only by its antenna gain. | Each model’s published maximum, per band; turn any access point down by hand | The same for every model: 15 dBm plus the antenna gain, less 2 dB (or the vendor’s average gain where it publishes one), “balanced to a 15 dBm client” | Even |
| Wall-plate access points | Any access point can hang on a wall with a facing; the pattern is fitted to Ubiquiti’s published antenna files | A facing for wall plates, three pattern classes, and wall plates placed along your walls automatically | Even |
Both run COST-231 multi-wall in the browser and publish how. The differences are in the inputs, and in whether you get a figure for how far to trust the answer.
| Dimension | WiFi Heatmap | Signal Plan | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wall materials Coated (low-E) glass is the one that surprises people: modern office glazing can stop more signal than brick. | 7 materials (drywall, wood, glass, coated / low-E glass, brick, concrete, metal), each with its own loss at 2.4, 5 and 6 GHz | 5 presets at 2.4 GHz (glass 2, drywall 3, brick 6, concrete 10, lift core 18 dB), multiplied by 1.2 at 5 GHz and 1.35 at 6 GHz | WiFi Heatmap |
| Drawing the walls Signal Plan added detection in its 9 November update. Neither has been compared with the other on the same plan. | By hand, or detected from the plan for you, free; straight horizontal and vertical walls only | By hand, or detected from the plan for you, free and labelled beta; straight walls only | Even |
| Furniture, people and clutter | An environment per floor (Office (furnished), Dense, Home, Open hall, Walls only), from the IEEE 802.11n/ax indoor models, on top of the walls | An “interior layout” path-loss exponent from 1.9 to 3.1, set by the building type you pick | Even |
| Several floors | One floor free; every floor in Pro | One floor free; multi-floor in Pro | Even |
| How far to trust it Its methodology page is unusually open about the formula. It does not say how close the answer lands. | A stated envelope of ±6–10 dB in a typical home or small office, with the method and its limits on /accuracy | The full formula and constants on its methodology page; no error figure (“Forecasts are planning estimates”) | WiFi Heatmap |
| PDF floor plans | Yes, the first page | Yes, any page of a multi-page PDF | Signal Plan |
| Areas to leave out | The margin outside the outer walls is left out on its own; you cannot mark a room to skip | Mark any area in or out of scope; access points are placed only inside it | Signal Plan |
Signal Plan will choose the model and the count for you, free. We plan more of the job around the access points.
| Dimension | WiFi Heatmap | Signal Plan | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Choosing the model and the count The row the assistants mention, and a fair one. | In Pro: “How many APs do I need?” and Optimise placement | Free: it recommends a model, a count and positions for the brand you pick | Signal Plan |
| Capacity: devices and throughput | Rooms with devices per m² and Mbps per device; the access point count capacity needs | Concurrent clients and Mbps per client; throughput and client capacity per access point | Even |
| Channels | Assigned per band and channel width, with an overlap layer on the map | Assigned, and shown as labels on the plan | Even |
| Cabling and PoE | Wiring closets, measured cable runs against the 90 m limit, PoE draw per closet and the switch to buy | Not planned; its own notes list PoE and cabling as things to check before deployment | WiFi Heatmap |
| Zigbee, Thread and Z-Wave | A mesh mode on the same engine, for smart-home radios | Wi-Fi only | WiFi Heatmap |
Signal Plan is free with ads and charges per clean export. We have no ads and sell Pro once.
| Dimension | WiFi Heatmap | Signal Plan | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ads | None, on any page or plan | Google ads on every page, planner included, and labelled affiliate links; Pro removes the ads | WiFi Heatmap |
| Account | None needed | None needed | Even |
| Where your floor plan goes | Nowhere: it stays in the browser, and exports are built there too | It stays in the browser; floor size, band and the chosen models go to its server for the recommendation | Even |
| The free export | A watermarked PNG with the first 5 access points, one floor | A watermarked image of the whole plan, and the access point list | Signal Plan |
| One clean export, once | €9 for a 7-day pass, every export that week | $6 per export, paid again after any change | Signal Plan |
| Pro, if you plan for a living | €39 once, or €29 a year | $59 a year or $9 a month, through PayPal | WiFi Heatmap |
| Branded client report | Pro: your logo, a page per floor, bill of materials, cabling page and method | Pro: your logo, a page per floor, AP schedules, equipment and capacity checks | Even |
Yes, with ads. The planner, the forecast, its access point recommendation and a watermarked image export are free, and Google ads show on every page, the planner included. A clean export costs $6 each time, and Pro is $59 a year or $9 a month through PayPal, which removes the ads and adds several floors and a branded report. Checked on its own pages on 19 November 2026.
No. Its methodology page says it sets every model’s power to 15 dBm plus the antenna gain, less 2 dB, to balance the access point with a typical phone. That is a legitimate design rule, and it means the model you pick changes its heatmap only by the antenna gain. Its gain and stream figures were checked against a vendor datasheet for 68 of its 195 models at its review of 9 November 2026. WiFi Heatmap uses the transmit power and antenna gain each vendor publishes, marks the 13 models whose vendor prints no power as estimated, and lets you turn any access point down.
Both run a COST-231 multi-wall model in the browser and both are planning estimates, not surveys. WiFi Heatmap tabulates each wall material separately at 2.4, 5 and 6 GHz, adds furniture and people from the IEEE indoor models, and states an envelope of ±6–10 dB for a typical home or small office on its accuracy page. Signal Plan publishes its formula in full but gives no error figure. Either way, check the result with a walk-around survey after install.
154 access point models across 20 vendors: Ubiquiti, TP-Link, Aruba, Ruckus, Cisco Meraki, Cisco, Zyxel, EnGenius, MikroTik, Cambium, Netgear, Fortinet, Huawei, Juniper Mist, Extreme Networks, Ruijie, WatchGuard, Grandstream, D-Link, Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise. That is every brand Signal Plan lists. Any other radio can be typed in by transmit power and antenna gain.
For one export, once: Signal Plan at $6, paid again after any change. For a week of revisions: WiFi Heatmap’s €9 pass, every export included. For planning as a job: WiFi Heatmap Pro at €39 once, against Signal Plan Pro at $59 every year. WiFi Heatmap’s free export is watermarked and includes the first 5 access points on one floor.
Comparing something else? vs WiFi Weave · vs UniFi Design Center · vs Omada Design Hub · vs Cambium · vs Hamina · vs NetSpot · vs Deconflict · every free planner, compared
Any vendor, in your browser, with no ads, no install and no account. Put the candidates side by side on your own floor plan and let the building choose.